Stars Sandwich Market

Updated 2026-11-06

Stars Sandwich Market serves weekday lunch in Indianapolis’s Mile Square, with the Philly steak drawing repeated praise from diners. Start with that sandwich; ribs with mac and cheese also earn an enthusiastic mention.

Stars Sandwich Market keeps a focused downtown schedule: three hours at lunchtime, Monday through Friday. Sandwiches anchor this Mile Square shop, and the Philly steak is the clearest draw in diners’ accounts, earning praise across multiple reports.

The praise extends beyond sandwiches to ribs with mac and cheese. Diners also mention fresh food and a variety of sandwiches and drinks, though their accounts of service diverge: some describe friendly, fast attention, while others report lengthy waits or incorrect orders. A tightly timed lunch break deserves that distinction.

Stars Sandwich Market is at 115 W Market St., Indianapolis. Hours are 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Monday through Friday; it is closed on weekends. Takeout and delivery are offered, and reservations are not accepted.

Keep exploring

Super Tortas Estilo Barrio

Indianapolis

Super Tortas Estilo Barrio serves generously sized Mexican sandwiches at inexpensive prices on Indianapolis’s Near Westside. Order a California, Acapulco or Oaxaca torta, all singled out by diners, or tackle the oversized super torta.

Sultana Cafe & Hookah Bar

Indianapolis

Sultana pairs Egyptian hookahs, Middle Eastern food and tabletop games with a late-night schedule in downtown Indianapolis. Order the Zeus fries and Turkish coffee, two standouts in diners’ accounts, or choose from craft cocktails and local beers on tap.

State Street Pub

Indianapolis

State Street Pub pairs an intimate live-music room with burgers, beer and a back patio on Indianapolis’s Near Eastside. Order a burger and a beer, or go for the stoner fries singled out in diner praise.

The Social American Tavern

Indianapolis

Inside Mile Square’s Hilton Garden Inn, The Social American Tavern serves American comfort food with Indiana touches and an attentive bar-and-dining-room staff. Order the smoked gouda and gruyere mac-and-cheese croquettes, bison meatloaf and Indiana sugar pie.