South Jersey rolls, shaved ribeye and Pennsylvania Dutch specialties give this Butler-Tarkington sandwich shop its regional focus Order a cheesesteak with Cooper Sharp American, or try Zern’s, a hoagie layered with ring bologna and a house red beet pickled egg
Culinary Dropout in Nora Plaza pairs comfort food and cocktails with live music and a relaxed gastropub setting Start with pretzel bites and provolone fondue, then order the signature fried chicken—or banana bread French toast at weekend brunch
Binkley's pairs neighborhood-bar comfort food with a patio at the corner of College and Kessler in Broad Ripple Start with stuffed garlic breadsticks or truffle fries, then order spicy chicken penne or chicken Alfredo
Yamallama Delicatessen serves pressed sandwiches, fresh salads and soups in Indianapolis’s Riverside neighborhood Start with the pastrami or Italian sandwich, or go for a salad with the tzatziki that diners single out
Wei Ramen serves homestyle ramen and Japanese comfort food in a casual, inexpensive Mile Square setting Pair a bowl with pork buns or gyoza, two recurring favorites in diners’ accounts
Twenty Two serves açaí bowls, fresh juices and made-to-order smoothies at downtown Indianapolis’s Garage Food Hall Order the PB Açaí Bowl for its peanut butter and cacao nibs, or the Shasta La Vista smoothie for a blend of leafy greens and tropical fruit
Tick Tock Lounge is a laid-back Near Eastside tavern with inexpensive pub food, a covered patio and a loyal following for its Bloody Marys Order one alongside a Reuben with tater tots, a sandwich-and-side combination diners single out
Thai Paradise pairs a vibrant, funky dining room with casual, order-at-the-window service in Indianapolis’s Mile Square Start with pad Thai or drunken noodles and a Thai tea, dishes and drinks that diners repeatedly praise
Tandoori Flame serves inexpensive Indian lunches and dinners in Indianapolis’s North Perry neighborhood, with creamy curries and generous portions drawing diners’ praise Order chicken tikka masala or butter chicken with garlic naan, and start with vegetable samosas
Taggart’s serves breakfast, lunch and dinner in the Wholesale District, with attentive service earning the most consistent praise from diners Start with the spinach-and-artichoke dip, then consider the Cuban sandwich or shrimp pasta
Super Tortas Estilo Barrio serves generously sized Mexican sandwiches at inexpensive prices on Indianapolis’s Near Westside Order a California, Acapulco or Oaxaca torta, all singled out by diners, or tackle the oversized super torta
Sultana pairs Egyptian hookahs, Middle Eastern food and tabletop games with a late-night schedule in downtown Indianapolis Order the Zeus fries and Turkish coffee, two standouts in diners’ accounts, or choose from craft cocktails and local beers on tap
State Street Pub pairs an intimate live-music room with burgers, beer and a back patio on Indianapolis’s Near Eastside Order a burger and a beer, or go for the stoner fries singled out in diner praise
Stars Sandwich Market serves weekday lunch in Indianapolis’s Mile Square, with the Philly steak drawing repeated praise from diners Start with that sandwich; ribs with mac and cheese also earn an enthusiastic mention
Inside Mile Square’s Hilton Garden Inn, The Social American Tavern serves American comfort food with Indiana touches and an attentive bar-and-dining-room staff Order the smoked gouda and gruyere mac-and-cheese croquettes, bison meatloaf and Indiana sugar pie
Hot chicken, chicken sandwiches and tenders at 1004 Virginia Avenue in Fountain Square, with a separate North Indy location in Carmel
Party wings and shrimp fried rice on Pendleton Pike Lemon pepper is a go-to; ask about honey garlic pepper, all flats and a harder fry
Mexican-American brunch, dinner and a tequila bar at 188 Westfield Road; A-Bocado Toast and breakfast platters anchor the daytime menu
Mexican cooking and margaritas at 13521 Tegler Drive, with elotes, quesadillas and seafood on the menu
A downtown Noblesville bar with a long wood counter, wings in seven sauce and dry-rub options, and a half-pound Party Melt on rye