At Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub in Carmel, the central choice is crust: traditional thinner crust or the signature Deep-Dish Sicilian. More than 40 toppings let diners build their own pie, while breadsticks—scratch-made and hand-rolled each day—give the table a straightforward starting order. Diners repeatedly praise the pizza, with deep dish earning particular attention.
The pub side has substance, too. The Piazza Bar lists more than 29 beers and 16 wines, including craft and local selections, while a self-serve craft root beer tap offers a nonalcoholic alternative. Fresh salads, pastas and baked sandwiches extend the menu beyond pizza; the Endless Salad Bar allows unlimited trips.
Diners describe an interior larger than the exterior suggests, with tables and booths arranged into smaller, more intimate areas. Plenty of televisions make it a practical choice for watching sports, and friendly, accommodating service is a recurring theme in reviews. The inexpensive price level adds to its appeal for a casual group lunch or dinner.
Noble Roman’s is at 1438 W Main St., just east of U.S. 31. It opens daily at 11 a.m., closing at 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Dine-in, carryout, delivery and online ordering are offered, and reservations are accepted.