Choosing pizza in Carmel can start with the format: a made-to-order slice at Greek Tony’s, Chicago-style pizza at Roselli’s or thin crust and deep dish at Rosati’s. Service matters, too, whether you want to sit down, pick up dinner or arrange food for a group.
These five businesses offer different starting points for that decision. Here’s where to find each one, with the menu and ordering details that help narrow the choice.
1. Bazbeaux Pizza — Bazbeaux’s Carmel location is at 111 W Main St, making it a pizza option to keep in mind when your plans center on Main Street. The business also lists Broad Ripple and downtown Indianapolis locations; choose the Carmel branch when looking up location-specific information.
2. Roselli’s Pizza — Roselli’s serves Chicago-style pizza at 4335 W 106th St, Suite 100, serving the West Carmel and Zionsville area. Lunch and dinner options include dine-in, carryout, curbside pickup and delivery, with online ordering available. A kids’ menu and catering throughout Central Indiana add options for family meals and larger gatherings.
3. Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse — Find Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse at 2430 E 146th St on Carmel’s north side. Its website provides menu access and online ordering, so you can choose your order before heading to the 146th Street location.
4. Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop — Greek Tony’s at 1732 E 116th St is the by-the-slice stop here, offering slices made to order throughout the day Monday through Saturday. The kitchen makes pizza and breadstick dough each morning, and the oversized breadsticks come covered in garlic butter. For group meals, ask about the reservable back party room and buffet-style arrangements with salad, breadsticks and pizza.
5. Rosati's Pizza — Rosati’s at 7241 E 146th St offers Chicago-style pizza in thin-crust and deep-dish formats for carryout or delivery. The menu also includes calzones, wings, pasta and Italian beef sandwiches, giving a mixed-order group alternatives to pizza. Online ordering and catering are available; delivery orders must be placed at least 15 minutes before closing.