Back to Fishers

The Cake Pantry

The Cake Pantry pairs scratch-made European-style pastries with espresso and custom celebration cakes in Fishers Start with a classic or pistachio croissant and a cappuccino, or choose a turkey croissant sandwich for a savory meal

The Cake Pantry
The Cake Pantry

The Cake Pantry’s name points toward celebrations, but its signature bake makes a case for an ordinary morning stop. The Fishers patisserie hand-laminates its croissants from scratch and bakes them fresh each morning, offering classic, chocolate, pistachio and strawberry versions. The coffee bar supplies lattes, cappuccinos and mochas to go alongside them.

Croissant sandwiches give the menu a savory counterweight. Diners praise the turkey and beef versions, with positive reviews repeatedly emphasizing the pastries’ freshness and the care in their preparation. The room earns recurring mentions for its cozy, welcoming feel — a setting for coffee and a sweet rather than just a cake pickup.

For celebrations, the bakery lists signature cakes in Nutella ganache, Biscoff, strawberry and pistachio, along with custom designs ordered through its online cake designer. Smaller sweets include éclairs, Danish pastries, tarts, mousse pieces and cake slices, so a whole cake isn’t required to explore the pastry selection.

The Cake Pantry is at 8800 North St., Suite 100, in Fishers. Hours are Tuesday through Saturday, 9 a.m. to 8 p.m., and Sunday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.; Monday is closed. Takeout is available, and custom cakes can be ordered online.

Keep exploring

More in Fishers
Wolfies Grill - Fishers in Fishers

Wolfies Grill - Fishers

Wolfies Grill pairs a warm, down-to-earth tavern setting with a patio, draft beer and American comfort food Start with the jalapeño mozzarella Fireside Cheese Sticks, then order the Tavern Burger topped with fried onion strings, provolone and boom boom sauce

Salt at Geist in Fishers

Salt at Geist

Salt at Geist serves seafood, sushi and cocktails in an upscale-casual Fishers setting suited to a leisurely dinner Order oysters on $2 Tuesdays, or take a cue from diners who praise the barramundi with orange blossom honey and sea salt sauce and lobster risotto

Walk-On's Sports Bistreaux in Fishers

Walk-On's Sports Bistreaux

Walk-On’s pairs a lively, TV-filled sports bar with Louisiana-inspired food and room for a crowd Start with Louisiana Loaded Nachos to share, then order blackened chicken Alfredo or the shrimp po’ boy diners praise

Four Day Ray Brewing in Fishers

Four Day Ray Brewing

Four Day Ray Brewing serves house beers and an eclectic pub menu in an industrial-inspired room in Fishers Start with a house brew and the fried green tomato pimento grilled cheese, a sandwich diners single out alongside the burger and pizza