Founded in 1999 by Joe Peterson, this independent Fishers steakhouse follows the classic occasion-dinner blueprint: prime beef, seafood and an extensive wine selection in chic surroundings. Diners repeatedly describe an intimate, relaxed atmosphere and welcoming service, particularly for birthdays, anniversaries and date nights. It is a splurge-priced dinner destination, with a separate private dining room for larger celebrations.
USDA Prime beef anchors a seasonally changing menu that uses Indiana produce and products when in season. Diners praise the steaks across several cuts and preparations, mentioning filet mignon, a filet trio and Kansas City strip. The seafood starters make an equally emphatic opening: Caviar and Oysters combines Ossetra caviar, crostini and crème fraîche with a choice of six oysters, while the Grand and Luxe Fire & Ice Towers include shrimp cocktail, oysters, crab cocktail, Ossetra caviar, calamari and chips.
The wine library runs to more than 200 labels, with by-the-glass choices including Jermann pinot grigio, Merry Edwards pinot noir and Oberon Napa Valley cabernet sauvignon. Monday features half off wines priced under $150 and $2 chef-selected oysters. Happy hour runs Monday through Thursday from 4 to 6 p.m., with half-price Classics & Twists cocktails and $3 off wines by the glass.
Peterson’s is at 7690 E. 96th Street in Fishers. Dinner hours are Monday through Thursday, 4 to 9:30 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, 4 to 10 p.m.; the restaurant is closed Sunday. Reservations are accepted online, and takeout is available.

