Pizza shares the spotlight with soup at Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub in Fishers. Chicken Gorgonzola soup earns repeated praise alongside the handmade specialty pies, giving this locally owned pub a distinctive starting point for dinner. Diners also single out the pizza crust, with pan-pizza fans praising its caramelized edges and balance of crunch and softness.
Supreme and Mad Greek pizzas appear among diners’ recommendations, as do soft pretzels served with beer cheese. Sandwiches and salads broaden the choices beyond pizza; one diner highlights grilled cheese with bacon and tomato. The bar’s selection of local microbrews on tap suits the pizza-and-pub format, with bottled beer, wine and cocktails also offered.
The setting accommodates both a neighborhood beer stop and a family meal. Booths and a spacious dining area sit alongside bar and patio seating, while a large private dining room handles parties, showers and happy-hour gatherings. Diners regularly praise the friendly staff, and the moderate price level keeps the emphasis on a casual outing.
Find Pearl Street at 10462 Olio Road in Fishers. It is closed Mondays, opens at 4 p.m. Tuesday, 11 a.m. Wednesday through Friday and noon on weekends, with evening kitchen service and a bar that stays open later. Reservations, carryout and delivery are available.