Osteria Rago sits just behind Bloomington’s Kirkwood Avenue, in a converted 1880s carriage house. The rustic, small dining room suits a casual Italian meal rather than a formal occasion; diners repeatedly praise the friendly service, and their accounts describe a lively room filled with conversation.
Pasta is made fresh daily. Spaghetti comes with pomodoro sauce for $16.99, or meatballs or ragu for $19.99; cacio e pepe combines parmigiano, romano and black pepper. Begin with the meatball appetizer, which pairs Fischer Farms beef and pork with pomodoro, fresh mozzarella and house-made focaccia. For a different opening, the burrata comes with prosciutto di Parma, apricot mostarda, arugula and crostini.
The wood-fired pizzas reach beyond Margherita without abandoning it. Patata Suprema layers roasted potato, bacon, Fischer Farms sausage and cheeses over white sauce, finished with rosemary-garlic-calabrese oil. The wild mushroom pizza combines confit garlic, pomodoro and four cheeses. Most pies run $18.99 to $20.99, and pizza earns recurring praise from diners. Wine, beer and cocktails are served, while a substantial sandwich selection gives lunch its own direction: the mortadella sandwich includes burrata, pickled red onions, pesto and arugula.
Osteria Rago is at 419 E. Kirkwood Avenue and opens Tuesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.; it is closed Sunday and Monday. Reservations through OpenTable are recommended for the small dining room. Takeout orders are accepted at 812-822-0694, and fresh pasta, ravioli and sauces are also sold at Bloomingfoods’ East and West stores.

